Aspen hostage-taker: I told you I was going to kill you

Jason Auslander
The Aspen Times
Brolin McConnell gets escorted into court in Aspen on Thursday.
Jeremy Wallace/The Aspen Times |

The most bizarre moment in the first court appearance Thursday by the man charged with holding three other men at gunpoint Wednesday occurred when one of the hostages addressed the court.

“After I saw the gun at my face, I thought of myself as a dead man,” Mark Meredith, 23, told Aspen District Judge Chris Seldin.

“I told you I was going to kill you,” said Brolin McConnell, 30, the Colorado Springs resident who was sitting in jailhouse orange and shackles, next to where Meredith stood, and who has been charged with the crime.

“He told me he was going to kill me and put a bullet through my temple,” said Meredith, a Vermont native and current Aspen resident.

“If …” McConnell said.

“The ‘if’ was if the cops showed up,” Meredith said.

“Well, they did show up and I didn’t kill you,” McConnell said.

“Because I ran,” Meredith said.

The nearly hour and a half-long hearing contained many such moments.

At one point, when Seldin attempted to explain the legal definition of first-degree kidnapping — which will require a mandatory minimum of 16 years in prison if he’s convicted of the charge — McConnell protested.

“Your honor, I didn’t kidnap anybody,” he said. “I just held him hostage.”

McConnell repeatedly told the judge, “I fear for my life.” He asked for and received a book of Colorado statutes so he could read along with the judge. He refused to sign mandatory protection orders forbidding his interacting with the 12 victims in the case. He asked why he wasn’t charged with possessing marijuana and guns together, because that’s “not legal,” he said.

“I don’t feel safe in this town, or anywhere really,” McConnell said. “I’m all alone in this world.”

In addition to the kidnapping charge, McConnell also is facing felony menacing and misdemeanor false imprisonment and prohibited use of a firearm. Seldin ordered him held in lieu of a $500,000 cash-only bond.

After the hearing, McConnell told a reporter he’s a real estate agent in both Colorado and Florida, though he said he lives in Colorado. He also admitted he didn’t know any of the men he held at gunpoint.

An employee at a Florida real estate firm listed on McConnell’s Linkedin profile said Thursday he didn’t work there anymore.

A woman who said she was McConnell’s mother answered the phone Thursday at a Colorado Springs real estate agency listed in the Linkedin profile. She was crying and said she knew what had occurred in Aspen on Wednesday.

“I don’t have any comment,” she said. “Things are very overwhelming right now.” She then hung up.

In an interview after court Thursday, Meredith said he and a friend from Aspen had gone up to the Lincoln Creek area to go bouldering, drink beer and camp. They first passed McConnell about 200 feet after the initial bridge. His gray Toyota Tacoma was parked at an angle in the road, though they were able to make it past, he said.

They went another 400 feet or so, and ran into two large, “military-type” guys in a white truck who told them soft-sided tent camping wasn’t allowed in the area because of recent bear incidents, according to Meredith and police reports. So they turned around, but had to get around McConnell’s truck again.

“He gets out and I thought he was going to help us,” Meredith said. “He walks around the front of the car, … then he looked back, pulled the gun out and pointed it at us.

“He said, ‘You guys are in on this.’ He had this whole idea he was being watched by cameras.”

He asked for Meredith’s friend’s iPhone and appeared to listen to it, he said. He made statements about the FBI and that drones were “all over the place,” Meredith said. At one point crows flew by and McConnell shot at them.

“He thought they were drones,” he said.

McConnell had a 9mm handgun and a .38-caliber and was pointing them at Meredith and his friend’s heads, he said.

“He was going back and forth whether he was going to shoot us,” Meredith said. “He said, ‘I’m going to put this bullet in your temple.’”

He opened the tailgate of his truck. He made the two men put their hands on his truck and asked if their hands were burning. They were, so Meredith asked if they could put their hands on their heads instead.

That was when a third car pulled up and a man with a cast on his foot got out, Meredith said. This was 21-year-old Blake Ramelb, who wrote a lengthy blog post Thursday describing his ordeal.

McConnell asked Ramelb about his race, according to Meredith and Ramelb. He told him he was 50 percent white and 50 percent Filipino, according to his statement. This seemed to make McConnell pick on Ramelb, Meredith said.

McConnell also had all three men take their shirts off to prove they didn’t have microphones or guns in their waistbands, Meredith said.

At that point, another car pulled up “and saved our lives,” Meredith said. That car distracted McConnell enough to allow Meredith’s friend to first run off, then Meredith was able to run away, he said.

That left only Ramelb, who couldn’t run because of the cast on his foot, he said in his blog.

“I knew if I had any chance, I would have to talk him out of shooting me,” Ramelb wrote in the blog. “I knew if I wanted to survive I needed to stall this guy from killing me at least so the cops could get in position to take him out.”

So he tried to talk to him about his family and the movie character Jason Bourne, he wrote. Then Pitkin County sheriff’s deputies arrived.

He told them he wanted $100 million, according to Ramelb and police reports. The deputies were trying to communicate with him, and McConnell had Ramelb yell back to them.

“The gunman threatened to shoot my kneecaps off, then wanted to shoot my surgical foot,” Ramelb wrote. “He had me turn away from him. I thought he was going to shoot me.

“Then he fired. I thought I was dead … but he missed. I felt the velocity of the bullet by my leg.”

Pitkin County Deputy Ryan Turner said he didn’t see the first shot, but vividly remembers seeing the second shot.

“I did definitely see him rip a shot off right at the hostage’s feet,” Turner said. “He said, ‘He’s next,’ and motioned with the gun at the kid.

“I was just like, ‘He’s going to kill this kid and there’s nothing we’re going be able to do about it.”

Eventually, Ramelb said he saw McConnell, who was sitting in his truck while Ramelb stood outside, move further into the truck with the gun still pointed at him.

“Then he turned around for a second,” Ramelb wrote. “When I saw that initial movement, I ran (hopped) behind the truck bed.”

Ramelb was able to escape. McConnell peacefully gave up almost as soon as Ramelb ran away, Turner said.

“It’s hitting me hard as I write down what happened to me yesterday,” Ramelb wrote, “but all I can say to myself is, ‘I’m alive.’

“From today on, I will always remember this experience. It’s not the best memory, but I realized at that moment that life is something worth living. I would like to thank everyone who gave me the fighting chance to still be here today.”

Support Local Journalism

Support Local Journalism

As a Summit Daily News reader, you make our work possible.

Summit Daily is embarking on a multiyear project to digitize its archives going back to 1989 and make them available to the public in partnership with the Colorado Historic Newspapers Collection. The full project is expected to cost about $165,000. All donations made in 2023 will go directly toward this project.

Every contribution, no matter the size, will make a difference.