Housing Divided, Part 1: Study confirms severity of Summit County housing crisis
About this seriesHousing Divided is a 13-part series from the Summit Daily News taking an in-depth look at our regional housing crisis. Over the next three months, in the Thursday edition of the Daily, we will explore the subject from every angle, featuring stories on seasonal workers, government and nonprofit solutions, homelessness, the impact of short-term rentals, the prevalence of second-home owners and deed-restricted housing.
By the numbers1,685: Total number of units estimated needed throughout the county by 2020
660: Number of those 1,685 units needed just to catch up to 2016 demand
$1,898: Average home rent in mid-2016
$850,000: Average single-family home sale price in 2015
3.8 percent: Average annual increase of home sale prices, 2012-15
2.25 percent: Unemployment rate in the county through June 2016, compared to 6 percent in 2012, meaning all those new workers need to find area housing
5A: Countywide ballot measure this November for a sales tax to establish a construction fund granting the county and its municipalities the ability to purchase land and/or build workforce housing
Accessory unit: Additional apartment that can be part of a single-family dwelling, that has its own kitchen to meet building and zoning requirements, for rent separately from any familial relationship
AMI (Area median income): Set of calculations commonly used nationwide to determine what a household, based on size, can afford on a lease or mortgage per person
Buy-down: Acquisition of market-rate property without a deed restriction or cap on appreciation that is transitioned into one that requires unit controls over appreciation over time and that an occupant be a full-time employee in the community to ensure it stays affordable long term
Cost burdened: Families or individuals who pay more than 30 percent of their income for housing
Deed restriction: Set of rules attached to a unit that specifies how the property can be used and how much it can be resold for over time. May also set requirements such as the tenant being a full-time employee, and how much the property’s value can appreciate
Market-rate: Fair market price or value for a property based on whatever the market will bear
Master-lease program: Program that converts short-term, vacation units previously available to the local workforce into long-term rentals. Provides property management services and financial assurances to the owner, and offers housing options to qualified, low-risk tenants
Editor’s note: This is the first in a 13-part series. Installments will appear each Thursday in the Summit Daily.
Two months ago, Norma Quezada found herself in a panic. The Summit County resident of 18 years had just received a notice to vacate her small apartment in Dillon Valley, where she’s lived with her two children and partner Brenda Chaparro for five years. The owner planned to renovate and sell the property. Quezada, originally from Mexico, had a month to find a new home.
“It was a surprise,” she said in Spanish, translated by her 17-year-old daughter, Mirka. “They didn’t give us much notice or anything, so it was just everything in a rush, like at the last moment. We were pretty stressed out and didn’t know where to look or who to ask for help.”
Quezada considered uprooting her family and moving to Albuquerque, where her mother lives. But on a friend’s recommendation she dropped by the Family & Intercultural Resource Center (FIRC) in Silverthorne in a last-ditch effort to stay. Luckily, Quezada, who is employed both as a Silverthorne restaurant kitchen worker and a hotel housekeeper in Dillon, discovered she qualified for a new program called the Housing Works Initiative. A collaboration between the FIRC, Summit Combined Housing Authority (SCHA) and The Summit Foundation, the pilot program converts short-term rentals into long-term options for renters looking for stability.
Soon Quezada and her family were moving beds, brown leather couches, family photos, flat-screen TVs and moose figurines into a two-bedroom condo in Wildernest. The 750-square-foot space is cozy (Mirka, and Quezada’s 8-year-old son, Guillermo, share a room, for example), but the family is happy to have found a home.
Participate in The Longevity Project
The Longevity Project is an annual campaign to help educate readers about what it takes to live a long, fulfilling life in our valley. This year Kevin shares his story of hope and celebration of life with his presentation Cracked, Not Broken as we explore the critical and relevant topic of mental health.
Quezada and her family are far from the only residents struggling to find shelter in Summit County’s notoriously difficult housing market.
Jennifer Kermode is on the front lines of the crisis. The housing authority’s executive director and her tiny staff field countless calls from would-be residents each year, particularly as winter approaches and seasonal jobs are filled. She is rarely the bearer of good news.
Kermode often ends up telling people to take the job, and then see if they can live temporarily with a co-worker, either on a couch or sleeping bag on the floor.
“That’s not a fun thing to say to young kids who feel that they’re here for their dream job and their dream year,” said Kermode. “There’s kind of this ugly underside to what it looks like (up here) when the sun goes down. That’s the bad part of it.”
That’s the reality of workforce housing woes in Summit County, and according to a new study released this month, the problem isn’t going away any time soon.
[iframe width=”640″ height=”315″ src=”https://www.youtube.com/embed/U-P3f70gW90?list=PL2_3maCYkXnG9w6LrqJizIBBS8_eNZz0j” frameborder=”0″ allowfullscreen></iframe]
The 2016 Housing Needs Assessment paints a dark picture, but it isn’t a surprising one for government officials close to the issue.
“The most important thing is this report confirms what we all sensed was going on,” said County Commissioner Thomas Davidson. “It’s still a problem. It’s not going away.”
Increasingly, it’s becoming more and more difficult for the county’s workforce to find affordable, long-term housing. The average price of condos and apartments in multi-family settings has risen 13 percent since 2012, ballooning from about $350,000 to approximately $400,000 in 2015. The average price for single-family homes has escalated comparably, by nearly $100,000 to more than $850,000 each. That equates to an annual sales growth of about 4 percent.
The rental market is at least as challenging. When the needs report was first produced in 2013, vacancies were routinely below 2 percent, and leases hovered around $1,280 per month. Today, for the majority of the year, spaces for rent communitywide are consistently under a half-percent and median monthly prices have soared to nearly $1,900. That accounts for a spike in the area median income (AMI), a formula commonly used to calculate what a household can afford on a lease or mortgage per person, of 30 percent.
“Back in the 2012-13 era, we were really trying to target a maximum 80 percent AMI for rentals and 100 percent for ownership,” said Kermode, “and now those have both slid up by 20 degrees. Rentals are up to 100 percent AMI and ownership up to 150. That’s kind of the new norm, which is disconcerting because we know that wages aren’t rising that high.”
The needs assessment concludes that the county will need 1,685 new units within the next four years to keep up with demand from a swelling population.
Construction in the region started to hit the skids with the economic downturn starting in 2008 and is mostly still rebounding, as of 2013. Meanwhile, wages in the community have remained relatively stagnant, often making people cost burdened with rent. Nonetheless, those who fantasize about escaping to live and work in the mountains are coming in waves, driving down the unemployment rate to 2.25 percent as of June 2016.
Statistics tell the story, but it all boils down to this: Home ownership for the county’s workforce has become unattainable.
“We’re not even talking about people being able to have the American Dream of a single-family home with a yard and a swing set and all of that,” said Davidson. “We’re talking about just anything that you can get into to have a place to live.”
‘Out of the Woods’
Because the free-market approach hasn’t supplied the housing required by a growing population, area governments have jumped into the home-building business with both feet. But that still might not be enough.
The assessment notes that the county would need 660 new units for the local workforce just to catch up to where it would need to be by the end of the current year. If the county’s development of the 45-acre Lake Hill parcel northeast of Frisco were completed tomorrow with its current projection of 436 units, it still would not eclipse that target. And for now, that’s seen as a 10-year project, anyway.
“I can’t promise you that by 2020 we’ll get to 1,685 units,” said Davidson. “Even if we got Lake Hill done, are we completely out of the woods? No. Over the last 30 years I don’t think that we’ve seen this kind of dramatic change in a four-year period. We need everybody pulling on the oars together.”
Breckenridge has completed three workforce housing developments in the last four years, providing more than 100 total units across the rental and ownership markets. Several more, including the 230 total homes in the Wellington Neighborhood, and 26 two-bedroom units by summer 2017 in a county-partnered project dubbed Huron Landing, are moving toward completion. Other large-scale, affordable construction on designated land is in the works, too.
Dillon, Frisco and Silverthorne also have their own projects at various planning stages, including 65 total units at the mixed-use, commercial-residential Dillon Gateway site, seven rentals at 308 Galena St. in Frisco, and Silverthorne’s 50-acre Smith Ranch plot for upwards of 200 units. But many details still need to be worked out for each, including the timeline for when those new living quarters will eventually come online.
“We cannot build our way out of this problem,” noted Kermode. “And even if we could, we can’t do it tomorrow. We really do have to start finding new boxes to think outside of on how to figure this one out. What used to be tools we could use that worked aren’t going to be effective anymore.”
‘It’s a Home’
Recent meetings between the region’s various housing authorities have been productive for sharing ideas to face these challenges throughout the Western Slope. Talk of getting the business community, both large and small, more involved to help come up with solutions has also been prevalent, as are county and municipality discussions for widening the number of buy-down properties that can become deed-restricted, on top of continuing to encourage homeowners to build out accessory apartment units. A countywide ballot item, 5A, to provide sales tax dollars to the local governments to build workforce housing is also up for vote this November. It could generate as much as $8 million a year.
The Housing Works Initiative master-leasing program is also one that will continue to expand. For Norma Quezada and her family — the fourth tenants in the experimental enterprise — it came at just the right time.
While the new lodging is slightly more expensive, and Quezada is a little nervous about getting around the high, winding roads once the snow starts this winter, she is happier with her living situation now, and thinks the extra cost is worth it for peace of mind, and her family.
“It’s more pretty,” she said. “It’s bigger, and we feel more comfortable with our neighbors.”
The chance at better job opportunities, education and a future for her children, mixed with the community being her longtime home, was too much to leave behind. Quezada is already trying to save up and improve her credit in order to buy an apartment in the county down the road. But in the meantime, she’s incredibly grateful to have found a safe landing in Wildernest and to not have to say so long to Summit.
“It’s a home,” she said through her daughter, Mirka, “a home for us that we know we can come to and not have problems, that we know it’s secure, and that it will be here. We have everything here, our friends, family, work, education, the natural beauty. This is home.”
Support Local Journalism
Support Local Journalism
As a Summit Daily News reader, you make our work possible.
Now more than ever, your financial support is critical to help us keep our communities informed about the evolving coronavirus pandemic and the impact it is having on our residents and businesses. Every contribution, no matter the size, will make a difference.
Your donation will be used exclusively to support quality, local journalism.
Start a dialogue, stay on topic and be civil.
If you don't follow the rules, your comment may be deleted.
User Legend: Moderator Trusted User