Trial begins for Justin Erwin, one of four accused in 2016 Silverthorne sexual assault
EAGLE — Dozens of Eagle County residents packed into a crowded courtroom at the Eagle County Justice Center on Monday morning to kick off the jury selection process in the long awaited trial of Justin Cayce Erwin.
Erwin, 41, is one of four men accused of sexually assaulting a woman who was too inebriated to give consent during an incident in Silverthorne on St. Patrick’s Day in 2016. The trial, scheduled through July 27, is expected to begin in earnest on Tuesday.
The prosecution and defense spent the day probing potential jurors, asking their opinions about the charge of sexual assault, their experiences dealing with intoxicated individuals and more. A jury of 15 individuals, including three alternates, will be chosen for the trial. Judge John McMullen will preside over the proceedings.
According to court documents, Erwin and three others—Paul Garvin, Michael Gelber and Ramon Villa— encountered the woman at a bar in Silverthorne after a night of drinking and celebrating the holiday and subsequently adjourned to a Silverthorne apartment where the alleged assault took place. Villa was renting the apartment at the time.
A statement of facts filed in court in June 2017 paints a troubling picture of an hours-long assault, informed largely by four graphic cell phone videos of the incident recorded by one of the men during the early morning of March 18. Descriptions of the videos describe the woman as having slurred speech and being in an “altered consciousness” throughout. An examination by a forensic nurse after the incident found numerous injuries to the woman, according to the document.
According to the document, a text message exchange between Erwin and Villa revealed that the woman had left the apartment by 9 a.m. when Villa woke up the next day.
With the accuser’s memory severely impaired, the videos served as the key piece of evidence for District Attorney Bruce Brown and the prosecution during the earlier trial of Paul Garvin. The videos were shown privately to the jury and were meant to provide insight into the woman’s state of mind at the time, a matter that will likely be pressed again in Erwin’s trial.
Erwin will be the third to head to court on the case, though it remains to be seen whether or not he’ll fare better than the others. Garvin was convicted on a Class 2 sexual assault charge in October 2017, and was sentenced to prison for a minimum of 16 years to life by Summit District Court Judge Karen Romeo. Gelber pleaded guilty to a reduced felony charge and two misdemeanors last month, and is scheduled to be sentenced this October.
Villa pleaded not guilty to felony sexual assault charges in December 2017, rejecting two plea deals from the prosecution. Villa is scheduled for a nine-day trial in Eagle County from September 4-14.
Erwin was originally slated to be tried alongside Gelber in January, but the trial was delayed and moved from Summit to Eagle County due to pre-trial publicity following the Garvin conviction. Gelber will be available to testify in Erwin’s trial.
Bruce Brown and Lisa Hunt are representing the District Attorney’s office during the trial, while Ashley Petrey and William Palmer are representing Erwin for the defense.
Support Local Journalism
Support Local Journalism
As a Summit Daily News reader, you make our work possible.
Now more than ever, your financial support is critical to help us keep our communities informed about the evolving coronavirus pandemic and the impact it is having on our residents and businesses. Every contribution, no matter the size, will make a difference.
Your donation will be used exclusively to support quality, local journalism.